Sounds from
motorcycles affect riders in surprising ways. Janelle
Kaz February 26,
2020
There
is more going on with the sounds from a motorcycle
and how it affects the human body than you might expect. Kevin Pak
The roar of a wide-open
throttle, the robust, throaty growl of a big V-twin, the thrumpy exhaust notes
of a vintage classic—just some of the motorcycle sounds that have entertained
petrol heads all around the world for as long as motorcycles have existed.
Whether it’s the engine noise, the gears
shifting, the tire-pavement interactions, body vibrations, or maybe even some
familiar rattling, motorcycles produce sound when they move. Even the
pitch and volume of an electric bike’s gear set makes a faint mechanical whine
which escalates with speed.
Combustion engine design and fine-tuned exhausts are huge components of the
sound and feeling of riding a motorcycle. Janelle Kaz
The particular sound of a
bike is very important to riders and motorcycle enthusiasts alike.
Anyone who rides knows there’s no comparison
for the suite of senses that makes up the experience of riding a motorcycle,
including sound.Motorcycle
brands know
the value of a well-crafted sound and how it affects potential buyers. Entire
departments are devoted to precisely tuning engine and exhaust design in order
to appeal to an innate emotional response resulting from sound.
Just consider how different
watching a motorcycle race on a screen is as opposed to actually being there,
simply because it lacks the auditory bombardment of a racetrack. Imagine being
at the racetrack, but in total silence. It doesn’t seem fathomable because we’re
so used to the immersive sound that comes along with the intensity and speed of
racing.
The
sensory immersion of actually being on a racetrack is unlike anything else.
Super Hooligans race at sunset in
Huntington Beach, California. Janelle Kaz
Different engines sing
different songs as they release compressed gas from the cylinders, then through
the exhaust valves and exhaust system, crafting their own unique sound
signatures. Some designs make such distinctive sounds that they are instantly
recognizable long before the bike comes into sight. Whatever your preference may
be, whether it is the balanced drone of a horizontally opposed engine or the
uneven interval firing of a V-twin, the sound signature is a strong
characteristic of our ride.
Even without a combustion
engine, some electric
bike makers have
added a digital exhaust, allowing you to choose a different sound for your
otherwise quiet bike by using an app on your phone.
It is clear that sound isn’t
just something that we hear, it is something we feel. Sound is
essentially touch at a distance. There is something unmistakable about the
powerful auditory and visceral sensation produced by motorcycles which never
gets old and enriches our lives every time one fires up.
Cam
Brewer with the RSD 750cc two-stroke named the “water buffalo,”
with its steep “ring-ding” sound waves
resulting from rapidly released exhaust. Janelle Kaz
Why Is Sound So
Important?
We are sensorial creatures,
moving about the earth in response to our environment. Human senses have been
shaped over time by evolution. Yet we do not see with our eyes nor hear with our
ears—we accomplish these things with our brain. The eyes and the ears are simply
the receptors of stimuli which are then transported to our brain to be
interpreted as a sight or a sound.
However, the outer ear you
see is not the only receptor of sound. Our entire bodies are conductors of
sound, including our bones. One of the first examples of sound conduction
through bone was from Beethoven, who began losing his hearing at the age of 26.
He continued composing music by resting his skull on the piano in order to
“hear” the vibrations of the piano strings. He also attached a thin rod to the
piano and would clench the rod between his teeth, experiencing the vibrations
through his jaw.
You can easily test this out
by completely blocking your ear canals (or just covering your ears) and using
your voice. You can still hear yourself because the vibrations coming from your
vocal chords are vibrating your jaw, your skull, and your sensitive inner ear.
This form of sound perception is known as bone conduction. It is with this same
technology that bone conduction headphones have been created.
Sending vibrations through
the skull via bone conduction bypasses the eardrum going straight to the
cochlea. The translated signal then travels from the auditory nerve to the brain
where it is perceived. Janelle Kaz
Rather than sending sound
through the auditory canal, bone conduction headphones bypass the eardrum
entirely, sending vibrations through the bones in your head to the cochlea, the
sensory organ which translates them into nerve impulses for the brain to
interpret.
This leaves your ears
available to listen for important sounds while on the road—auditory cues which
could save your life, such as oncoming traffic, squealing tires, or emergency
sirens.
This technology has already
proved helpful for soldiers in war zones, so that the person on the ground can
hear communication through bone conduction while still listening to what is
happening around them through their ears.
It’s
hard to imagine the engine and exhaust noises being absent from the racetrack
and pits, but this silent speed may be
our future. Andy DiBrino and his father getting ready to hit the track.
Janelle Kaz
Additionally, this is how
elephants communicate over such long distances. Bone is a solid structure and
therefore a very fast conductor of vibrations. Elephants stomp on the ground,
signaling to other elephants via low-frequency seismic vibrations. The
vibrations travel along the earth and up through the bones of another elephant,
reaching the cochlea and the brain. The males even touch their trunk to the
earth as a way to triangulate the direction in which the female is sending the
signal from.
Water also transmits these
vibratory sound waves over great distances and some whale skulls and mandibles
(jawbones) have acoustic properties which conduct low frequencies directly to
the inner ears.
As you probably know, we’re
made up of two-thirds water. However, you may not know that because the water
molecule is so small, this quantity translates into 99 percent of our molecules.
Water is a great conductor of sound.
You
don’t just hear your motorcycle with your ears—our entire bodies are conductors
of the vibrational energy of sound. EL3 Productions
Additionally, it has been
found that humans also listen through the largest organ in the body, our skin. A
type of sensory receptor covering our skin at varying densities known as
mechanoreceptors are capable of sensing sound.
Therefore, depending on the
bike you’re on, there is a very particular sound that emanates through you as
you ride. Not just via the vibrating of your eardrum, but traveling through your
entire body—your skin, your organs, and your bones.
It is no wonder we get so attached to our motorcycles.
Interestingly, there is
promising research on the healing properties of certain vibrations, such as
those discovered by Dr. Lee Bartel in his findings of how sound can stimulate
cells in the body and brain to increase blood flow. So far, this treatment has
shown significant positive effects for sufferers of Alzheimer’s, dementia,
depression, and fibromyalgia.
Of course, there has yet to be any
scientific studies done on the physiological ways in which the sounds and
vibrations of a motorcycle affect the human body and mind, but if this
research were to take place, I would be very intrigued to learn the results.
Perhaps, like me, you consider your time on two wheels meditation in motion and
feel a sense of relief while out on the road.
Clearly, there are other sensory stimuli at play which likely also attribute to
an increase in overall well-being while riding, such as the movement of wind,
the experience of velocity, the novelty—whether you’re riding somewhere new or
simply noticing changes in your surroundings, perhaps the sun on your face,
and/or the views that you travel through (hopefully beautiful land- or
urban-scapes).
Drag
racing at the Moto Beach Classic event in Huntington Beach, California. Kevin
Pak
What Is Sound?
The majority of us are so used to sound being such a huge part of life that we
never stop to wonder what, exactly, sound is. Sound is a pressure wave created
by vibration through a medium. Sound is a form of energy, a force which sets
surrounding particles in motion, thus transporting this energy through
oscillations in air pressure—as a wave—through space and time.
These sound waves need a medium to travel through, such as a solid, liquid, or
gas. It is true that there is no sound in a vacuum, however this does not
entirely apply to outer space. The majority of space as we know it isn’t an
empty void; particles still exist, but they might be so spread out that the
sound traveling through them is at a low enough frequency that the human ear
cannot detect it.
Harmful
Vibrations
Ever since I started
spending a lot of time out on the road, I’ve met at least a dozen older riders
who have felt compelled to express the need for ear protection while riding. It
isn’t the bombastic sounds from the exhaust, but rather the damaging effects
from the turbulent airflow around your head—the wind.
Studies have shown that even
a full-face helmet cannot completely protect your ears from the permanent damage
caused by wind. Just a couple of years ago, research was conducted which
revealed some pretty scary results. The studies showed that permanent hearing
damage can be caused after only 15 minutes of riding at 62 mph (100 kph) without
earplugs. Just as you might expect, the faster you go the less time it takes to
cause irreparable harm.
Filtered earplugs are
recommended in order to protect motorcyclists from the severe damage caused by
the high-frequency wind, while still allowing them to hear lower-frequency
sounds, such as their engine, human speech, and oncoming traffic.
A recent study tested a
novel acoustic material designed to significantly reduce noise caused by the
turbulent wind around the helmet. It is a porous, natural leather foam set
inside the motorcycle helmet with a remarkable ability to decrease the noise
caused by a wide range of high frequencies.
Mount
Wilson, a peak located in the San Gabriel Mountains, with its Radio Ridge
Antenna Farm receiving a barrage of radio waves serving the Los Angeles area.
Sam Ray
Although sound is currently an inextricable feeling
of riding motorcycles, we should respect the powerful force of wind regardless
of what bike we’re on, and recognize the incredible nature of our sensitive
eardrums. Wind, after all, carves canyons and shapes mountains. Losing the
ability to hear our loved ones in old age is incredibly sad, especially if it
can be prevented via a combination of bone conduction headphones and filtered
earplugs while riding—which still applies for quiet electric bikes.
For as long as humans have recognized that sound
helps or alters mood and mind states, we’ve been using technology to induce some
desirable state of mind. Perhaps this will someday be applied to electric
bikes—just imagine restorative binaural beats emanating from your running
motorcycle, mechanical vibrations designed to improve brain and other organ
functioning or even bone density as you ride. Only time will tell where the
unseen waves of sound carry us.
Two Questions
Do you have any experience with filtered earplugs or
bone conduction headphones while out on two wheels?
As we
transition away from non-renewable fossil fuel sources, do you imagine a quiet
future for motorcycles and racing?
READERS COMMENTS
·
28 February, 2020
The lack of combustion engine intake and exhaust sounds in electric motorcycles
is a major impediment to my acceptance of the breed. I know there's some sound
in an EV, but not what I'm looking for.
·28 February, 2020
There's nothing more surreal (and pleasurable) than the odd moment when a 60 mph
tailwind makes my ride dead silent, and I throttle down significantly such that
the bike sounds like it's idling in the driveway, and you watch the gorgeous
desert landscape peel away before you as you pierce it on a thin ribbon of
highway at breakneck speeds. Bicycling silently in an urban environment presents
a similar thrill, improved by endless details you don't see, hear, feel or smell
when driving, or even motorcycling. (We all know how motorcycling provides ten
times the aroma of nature than driving does. Bicycling gives about twice that of
motorcycling.) Ah, but road racing. That where the sound and vibration of the
engine tells you how fast you are going, what rpm your engine is at, and even
what gear you are in. You find yourself ignoring the tachometer, yet shifting
just before the rev limiter kicks in. You discover that the proper amount of
braking and downshifting is determined by "muscle memory", which is where your
subconscious brain automatically decides what to do, based on sound and feel as
much as sight. You achieve the same level of skill when training for a pilot's
license. You can ignore all the instruments, because your ears and buttocks tell
you what the speed, roll, altitude and vertical speed indicators are saying.
Yes, I do believe the blind could be taught to ride and fly. Drive a car? Nope.
28 February, 2020
"You achieve the same level of skill when training for a pilot's license. You
can ignore all the instruments, because your ears and buttocks tell you what the
speed, roll, altitude and vertical speed indicators are saying." Umm... no. In
fact, the exact, complete opposite is true - as JFK Jr. and many, many other
deceased pilots and their families would strongly concur. Google "spatial
disorientation" - an all-too-common killer in aviation - where relying on your
physical senses "based on sound and feel as much as sight" will all but
guarantee your demise.
28 February, 2020
We alter exhaust systems to get sound we like. We alter the volume and/or the
tone.
Same thing can be accomplished with an electric bike by simply adding a
computerized synthesizer that could produce any tone or volume we want. No more
synthetic than altering the sound with different tubes and mufflers. But with
the added ability to change the tone or volume in an instant instead of being
fixed. The thing that turns me off on electric bikes - no gear box.
There is something about changing gears while accelerating that is exhilarating
to me.
Oddly enough, from what I've understood, some Hondas that are running CVTs have
"shift points" designed in to give the feeling of shifting. People associate it
with acceleration. Honda did a similar thing on their hydrostatic ATVs, having
either a constant variable swash plate operation or a manual five position set
up that "shifted". I want an electric bike that can make the noise I want, be it
XR750 or H2 with chambers, that has a gear box to get the rush of the sound and
the shifting.
·Sp12 January, 2024
Within the past few years Ive been using the foam earplugs on every ride.
Inserting them deeper practically eliminates all wind and exhaust noises. It's a
satisfying quiet which makes me focus more on what I see on the roadside and
feel with the bike. Shifting according to vibrations.
·29 December, 2023
It's always been (as an engineer) my understanding that sound, especially
sub-audible and very low bass sounds, also set up resonances in the cavities of
the body - stomach, chest, etc. These are different for all people and, along
with all the effects mentioned in the article, account for tastes
4 March, 2020
I think the coolest thing about electric bikes is the quiet; to stand up on the
pegs so you can't see it either is for me, magical. Like flying in a dream. That
said, I've [mostly] used ear plugs, especially while touring, since I started
riding 50 yrs ago and today at 63 I still hear well. Also, earplugs make a long
day in the saddle WAY less tiring
2 March, 2020
Riding is a different experience when you can hear sounds like the tires or
clutch chatter instead of exhaust noise. Spectators like the noise more. Kaz,
which sounds better: a scout 60 on the open highway or an enduro on a dirt road?
Or the scout on a winding forest road?